They can make conversation. They think they are interesting. They think you find it flattering that they can perpetually find flaws in you.
Not very different from the people I described in my earlier post on Preachers, these people are a very creative, inventive and socialising lot. They are generally talkative and can’t stand not making conversation. So once you run out of the standard niceties, you’re stuck.
That’s when they are at their creative best. They’ll take one long hard stare at you and immediately come up with a list of imaginary flaws that you have. They know you don’t have them, or at least you or anyone else is not bound to suffer because of them in a long time to come. But it makes conversation. If you last two or three sentences, you’re done for. That’s about the time they start believing whatever they’ve just said to be true.
The best defence you have is to agree with them. Make up some way in which you are going to improve yourself. The more you try to counter them or argue about the baselessness of the conversation, the more they will try to convince you and will end up convincing themselves more. If before the end of the dialogue they are completely convinced, your life could turn into hell. They’ll make sure you spend the next few weeks, months or years trying to fix something you didn’t have in the first place.
As a very vague analogy, assume you and your friend are standing in front of a bullock cart. You have just told him that you’re going to travel to Scotland on that bullock cart and have run out of conversation. Now imagine him sizing you up, the environment and one deep breath later saying, "You should get the engine on that bullock cart checked. It’s a long trip and you don’t want to get out and push it in case something goes wrong." That’s very helpful advice, except, you argue, "The bullock cart doesn’t have an engine." Imaging the agony you’ve just put him through because you stood up to argument. You should have asked him for directions to the nearest service station to get the engine checked, instead you countered his very statement. Add a petrified look to our conversationalist, "It doesn’t even have an engine? This is way too unsafe. You’re not going to Scotland on that. What you need to do is save up huge loads of money for the next three years, buy a good brand of a horse carriage and only then make this trip."
Of course, most such conversations I encounter are at a far more personal level, usually some aspect of my personality. And you’ll have to trust me when I say that it’s not my ego which prevents me from taking ‘feedback’ from my friends. Their pointers really are meaningless. These are the kind of people I’m stuck with.